DAY 1 - A Familiar Premise

[Watari]

May 2, 2020 22:16:08 GMT -6 Naomi Misora said:

The best course is to find scum early and kill it, right? Besides, it's okay to kill Hideki by mistake because he admitted that he wasn't already power. It's no use to risk revealing our identity rather than the risk of mislynch

The risk of a mislynch and the risk of revealing one's identity is the same: a town death. We can't afford to just be lax on lynching, because blind firing is more likely to hit town than scum.
Hideki has for sure looked bad, but this mentality is not beneficial to town at all.

[Misa Amane]

May 2, 2020 22:34:37 GMT -6 Teru Mikami said:

May 2, 2020 19:44:54 GMT -6 Misa Amane said:

I don't trust Hideki.

Has anyone given any reasoning to the No Lynch idea yet? I asked about it because I don't understand it!

yes i did nd a bunch of ppl commented on it. did u really ask and then not read up? there is like 50 posts

No one has explained it to me in a way that makes sense to me.

[Naomi Misora]

May 2, 2020 23:07:31 GMT -6 Watari said:

May 2, 2020 22:16:08 GMT -6 Naomi Misora said:

The best course is to find scum early and kill it, right? Besides, it's okay to kill Hideki by mistake because he admitted that he wasn't already power. It's no use to risk revealing our identity rather than the risk of mislynch

The risk of a mislynch and the risk of revealing one's identity is the same: a town death. We can't afford to just be lax on lynching, because blind firing is more likely to hit town than scum.
Hideki has for sure looked bad, but this mentality is not beneficial to town at all.

It's not the same because not only one person but many people are exposed. And it's not a blind fire. Because it looks like scum.

[Light Yagami]

The only logic to a no lynch is very flawed. It requires the hope of scum not having a way to sleuth people out regardless of figuring out who they are, or other events or mechanics that may come along.

Your confirmed townie and your triple voter want a lynch, and we will have one. So let's agree to one.

I see there is demand for the miller claim to be voted, but I don't see a need for me to add to it at this time. But push comes to shove I am happy to move back to it.

[Soichiro Yagami]

I agree we could just end the day on Hideki if nothing else comes up but we should probably get more information if we are to keep day going. What do you suggest Light?

[Light Yagami]

I'm concerned that there are so few people talking in general. I'm not sure if it's because of people being concerned about being discovered or because they just aren't paying attention so far.

While I am of the opinion a no lynch isn't a good idea, the idea of defaulting to lynch an inactive may not be best course either this game... this isn't exactly a case where being a lurker is exactly damning. It is still a very bad look however.

[Soichiro Yagami]

May 2, 2020 16:02:32 GMT -6 Shuichi Aizawa said:

##Vote: No lynch

 only post of the game... not a good look >.>

[Shuichi Aizawa]

##unvote

##vote: Soichiro

[Hideki Ide]

Quoting is weird on this board, so here:

Misa is Scum because she's using "not trusting" as an excuse to go after someone, as opposed to "thinking is mafia".

Town try to lynch people who they think are mafia, not people they 'don't trust'.

'Don't trust' is not a term that Town uses.

##Vote: Mina

Also, since I assume some of you are just unintelligent Town, I will be forced to throw this bone.

I am power. I am also Miller.

[Hideki Ide]

##Vote: Misa

name was spelled wrong

[Soichiro Yagami]

##vote:Shuichi Aizawa

Two post. Two bad votes.

[Hideki Ide]

Soichiro, vote Misa, or you are Scum.

[Hideki Ide]

I mean, seriously, a person has made two posts that are exclusively votes, and you have the AUDACITY to counter-vote that? Come on, dude.

[Soichiro Yagami]

I could just vote you. Someone who comes in to just vote and not say anything is super scummy Bruh. Providing no content is Anti town.

[Hideki Ide]

Why would you vote me? Are you claiming Scum?

[Hideki Ide]

Here's a question - when's the last time a Miller claim actually was Scum? The last time I can remember was a game with like, three Miller claims.

Truth is that Miller should be a banned role, because the meta is rigid. But you know, might as well follow it when you draw it.

[Light Yagami]

No I think Soichiro has the right idea here

##Unvote
##Triple: Shuichi

[Soichiro Yagami]

How would I be claiming scum? You havent looked town that's why I'd vote you.

[Soichiro Yagami]

Like I said Shuichi Aizawa does not look good from the 2 non context post so hence why im voting that over you.

[Shuichi Aizawa]

##unvote
##vote: Soichiro

[Hideki Ide]

I mean, I agree that it's poor play to let someone exclusively only make votes and not contribute to the game. I'm just salty because Miller is a shitty role, and it fucking floors me that people continue to use it in games, and I actually draw it and have to play along with the meta, and immediately some baddies come in and vote me, and then some dumb triple voter throws their undeserved weight behind it.

[Hideki Ide]

May 3, 2020 1:21:46 GMT -6 Soichiro Yagami said:

How would I be claiming scum? You havent looked town that's why I'd vote you.

Because the only people who would be pushing for me to be lynched because I claimed Miller are Scum or dummies who can't think for themselves.

[Hideki Ide]

But fine, this is obnoxious, so...

##Unvote:
##Vote: Shuichi

If people don't annoy me into not posting anymore tomorrow, then I'll be sitting on him until he says real words. Misa is still probably Scum though.

[Shuichi Aizawa]

##unvote

##vote: Hidek

[Light Yagami]

May 3, 2020 1:33:28 GMT -6 Shuichi Aizawa said:

##unvote

##vote: Hidek

Are you able to post anything besides votes?

[Soichiro Yagami]

So you're just going to troll us?

[Light Yagami]

May 3, 2020 1:25:56 GMT -6 Hideki Ide said:

I mean, I agree that it's poor play to let someone exclusively only make votes and not contribute to the game. I'm just salty because Miller is a shitty role, and it fucking floors me that people continue to use it in games, and I actually draw it and have to play along with the meta, and immediately some baddies come in and vote me, and then some dumb triple voter throws their undeserved weight behind it.

I voted you before your claim to create discussion. At the time of me saying I would support you if nothing else happened were tied with No Lynch for the current majority. 

Just create content and show us that you're town and prove that you shouldn't be considered a lynch option. Don't cry about meta or your claim. Be productive, not counterproductive.

[Hitoshi Demegawa]

May 2, 2020 18:31:19 GMT -6 Lind L. Tailor said:

May 2, 2020 15:47:08 GMT -6 Hitoshi Demegawa said:

I took Naomi's post for a joke. But now I that seems to be clearly not be the case.

So what does that say to you?

That she should present a reason for why she responded in such a bizarre way.
Naomi, can you manage that?
Her willingness to sacrifice Hideki also bothers me, as does a lot of talk around Hideki.

But...I do not comprehend Hideki's argument against Misa either. Getting hung up on someone saying 'I dont trust' is a stunningly lazy approach towards voting someone.

[Hideki Ide]

If you can actually only vote, then please put a vote on who you actually think is mafia instead of this worthless countervote shit.

[Hitoshi Demegawa]

So Shuichi is a waste of time.

For a second I could believe he was going somewhere with his Soichiro vote, seeing as how I have not been impressed with him much myself.
Alas, he be joking about.